Skip To Content
Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries poster

Where To Watch Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries

Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries comes from UP TV.

  • Running
  • Since 2025
  • 1 Season
  • 8 Episodes
  • 60 Min
  • Drama, Crime

The Verdict On Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries

8 HoursTo Watch 8 Episodes

Best Episodes Only, 4 Hours

Short on time? Watch just these 4.

  1. S1 E1 The Buggy Before The Horse 5.7
  2. S1 E2 A Season of Secrets 6.0
  3. S1 E6 Stitch in Time 5.2
  4. S1 E8 When There's a Will 6.2

Safe To Skip

The lowest rated, well under the show's 5.2 average.

  1. S1 E5 Simply Vanished 4.2
  2. S1 E4 Off the Beaten Path 4.2

About Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries

Cheryl Cooper escapes to an Amish community in Sugarcreek, Ohio, to manage a gift shop after a failed engagement. Drawn into one mystery after another, Cheryl quickly realizes her sharp instincts and outsider perspective are exactly what this tight-knit community needs.

Highest rated episode, Season 1 Episode 8, When There's a Will, at 6.2.

Find The Trailer On YouTube

Every Episode Of Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries

9+8+7+6+Under 6Unrated

Season 18 Episodes

12345678

More Like Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries

Breaking Bad2008 · Netflix9.2Nocturne2026 · Apple TV9.0Game of Thrones2011 · Hulu8.9Vikings2013 · Netflix8.6Fargo2014 · Hulu8.6Fringe2008 · Hulu8.6